Key points

  • The first question is not how many hours were worked, but whether an employment relationship exists and whether the work permit and lawful residence requirements are satisfied.
  • A contract clause saying overtime is unpaid, or that salary is an all-in package, does not automatically displace mandatory working-time and rest standards; the wage structure and actual performance still matter.
  • Comprehensive and flexible working hours require administrative approval and the approval must match the actual position. Without approval, standard hours are generally applied.
  • Overtime uses 21.75 paid days, with 150%, 200% and 300% rates for working days, rest days and statutory public holidays.
  • The employee must first provide evidence of overtime. Where attendance evidence is controlled by the employer and not produced, the employer may face an adverse inference.

Opening note | Foreign-related overtime disputes often turn on more than the number of hours worked. The first questions are whether the employee can claim under PRC labour law, whether a contract clause excluding overtime is effective, how the wage base is determined when pay comes from both China and overseas, and who can prove the overtime. This article addresses those four thresholds in sequence.

1. First threshold: employment status and applicable rules

The first question is not how to apply 21.75. It is whether an employment relationship exists at all.

Article 22 of the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China provides that the working time, rest, leave, occupational safety and health, and social insurance of foreigners employed in China are governed by the relevant State rules. This is the direct basis for applying Chinese working-time and rest standards to foreign employees.

The provision has threshold requirements. Article 2 concerns foreigners who have not obtained settlement rights; Article 5 requires the employer to obtain an employment permit before employing the foreigner. Where no lawful permit exists, or the facts do not fall within Article 4 of the 2025 Interpretation (II), the employment relationship will usually not be recognised.

Article 4 of Interpretation (II) identifies three positive scenarios:

  1. the foreigner has obtained permanent residence status;
  2. the foreigner has obtained a work permit and is lawfully staying and residing in China;
  3. the foreigner has completed the relevant procedures under State rules.

Outside those scenarios, a statutory overtime claim usually loses its foundation. Work already performed may still support a claim for remuneration through a service relationship, invalid-contract rules or another civil-law route, but it is no longer a Labour Law overtime claim in the ordinary sense.

Hong Kong, Macao and Taiwan residents follow a different historical path. The employment-permit requirement for these residents was removed in 2018, so the old permit-based cases should not be applied without checking the change. A foreign permanent residence holder no longer needs an employment permit, but the precise scope of labour rights still depends on the contract and local practice.

2. Second threshold: does a “no overtime pay” clause work?

Cross-border templates often contain two kinds of clause:

  1. an express statement that the employee may work additional hours without overtime pay, or that unpaid overtime is expected;
  2. a low normal-working-time wage combined with an annual salary, bonus or allowances, with the employer arguing that overtime is already included.

The first kind cannot automatically displace mandatory working-time and rest standards. Those standards protect basic labour conditions and are not simply waived by agreement.

That does not mean every all-in salary arrangement is invalid. Courts examine:

  • whether the contract separates normal-working-time pay, bonuses, allowances and overtime pay;
  • whether payroll records consistently identify those components;
  • whether the employee knew and accepted the structure;
  • whether attendance, overtime approval and work arrangements exist;
  • whether the stated normal wage is below the local minimum wage.

A vague statement that “the annual salary includes overtime” is usually weak without a wage breakdown, attendance records or evidence of actual performance.

Conversely, where the contract, payroll, bank records and performance practice align, the employer may argue that some overtime was already paid. The court will still examine whether normal-working-time pay was artificially suppressed or below the minimum wage.

3. Third threshold: special working hours and arranged overtime

Comprehensive working hours and flexible working hours are not systems an employer can adopt by internal decision alone.

Article 13 of the Interim Provisions on Wage Payments provides that:

  • where comprehensive working hours are approved by the labour administration, hours above the statutory total for the approved cycle are treated as extended hours and paid accordingly;
  • employees on approved flexible working hours do not receive the ordinary working-day and rest-day overtime treatment.

The key requirements are administrative approval and a match between the approval and the actual position. Approval is normally position-specific, not a blanket status for every employee. A signed confirmation letter or an internal rule saying that “senior managers are on flexible hours” is usually insufficient without the approval.

An overtime approval policy is another common defence. A rule that “overtime without prior approval does not count” does not automatically defeat a claim where the employer actually arranged, required or knowingly accepted the work. Courts look at:

  • whether the employer arranged or required the additional work;
  • whether supervisors knew about and accepted the output;
  • whether attendance, meetings, emails and deliverables show continuous work;
  • whether the approval process was used to avoid recording overtime that had already occurred.

4. Fourth threshold: 21.75, the three rates and cross-border pay

Article 44 of the Labor Law sets three rates:

Situation Rate Can time off replace payment?
Extended hours on a working day At least 150% No
Rest-day work without equivalent time off At least 200% Yes, equal time off may remove the payment
Work on a statutory public holiday At least 300% No

The usual hourly-rate formula is:

Hourly rate = monthly wage ÷ 21.75 ÷ 8

The 21.75 figure comes from Article 2 of MOHRSS Notice 2008 No. 3, not 23.5. Using 23.5 as the divisor understates the hourly rate. The overtime base is normally the normal-working-time wage and may not fall below the local minimum wage; whether bonuses, allowances and subsidies are included varies by locality.

Cross-border pay is more complicated. Money paid overseas is neither automatically included in the overtime base nor automatically excluded. The key question is whether it is consideration for normal working time. Contracts, offers, payroll, domestic and overseas bank records and exchange-rate evidence may establish that fact.

Housing, travel, overseas-posting and similar reimbursements should normally be separated from ordinary wages. Mixing every payment into a single “annual package” can create both a wage-base dispute and an employer argument that overtime was already included.

5. Fifth threshold: proving the overtime

The burden of proof is not reversed in full.

Article 42 of Interpretation (I) provides that an employee claiming overtime must first prove that the overtime occurred. Where there is evidence that the employer controls evidence of the overtime and the employer refuses to produce it, the employer may face an adverse inference.

The employee should therefore establish:

  • that the employer arranged, required or knowingly accepted the additional work;
  • the dates, periods and approximate duration;
  • that the employee produced the relevant work;
  • that attendance, meeting or other records are controlled by the employer.

Evidence commonly used in foreign-related cases includes:

  • time-zoned calendar invitations and meeting records;
  • emails, messages and task-management records from the overseas headquarters;
  • domestic attendance, access-control, rosters and payroll;
  • domestic and overseas bank records showing the pay structure;
  • deliverables and supervisor confirmations.

Foreign-language evidence usually requires a Chinese translation. Evidence formed overseas may require notarisation, authentication, an apostille or another treaty-based procedure. Emails alone generally prove communication, not the complete duration of work.

Employers are also expected to retain wage-payment records, generally for at least two years. For periods beyond that, the employee may face a heavier evidential burden.

6. Sixth threshold: arbitration limitation and procedure

Overtime is labour remuneration, but limitation issues still matter.

Article 27 of the Labour Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law provides that:

  • during an ongoing employment relationship, a claim for unpaid labour remuneration is generally not subject to the one-year limitation;
  • after termination, the claim should be brought within one year.

The absence of a limitation during employment does not mean the evidence will remain available. Attendance, systems and bank records become harder to obtain over time. Evidence should be preserved and the procedural route assessed early.

Labour disputes ordinarily go to arbitration before litigation. Where a foreign employee cannot establish an employment relationship, the arbitration commission may reject the case on standing grounds, and a civil contract, service relationship or tort route may need to be assessed instead.

7. Chinese employees posted overseas

For a Chinese employee posted overseas, the analysis does not stop at the identity of the contracting entity.

Where the employee remains employed by the domestic sending entity, with domestic payroll, social insurance, attendance and management continuing, an overseas posting does not automatically terminate the domestic employment relationship. Whether overtime is payable still depends on the actual work arrangement, working-hour system, pay and evidence.

Where both the performance of the contract and the actual workplace are overseas, Article 43 of the Law on the Application of Laws to Foreign-Related Civil Relations may apply. An employment contract is generally governed by the law of the place where the employee works; where that is difficult to determine, the employer’s principal place of business may apply. Mandatory rules protecting labour rights may still apply directly.

Overseas labour cooperation is a different structure. It generally involves organising workers to work abroad for a foreign employer, and a domestic intermediary or service contract does not automatically create a domestic employment relationship. The claim and calculation must follow the contracting parties, management relationship and actual performance.

8. Compliance points for employers

  • Do not use a vague all-in salary clause without a wage breakdown.
  • Obtain approval for special working hours and ensure the approved position matches the actual role.
  • Keep attendance, overtime approvals, payroll, domestic and overseas payments and allowance items consistent.
  • Preserve time-zoned meeting arrangements, work assignments and deliverables for cross-border work.
  • Review work-permit dates, wage structure and working-hour arrangements before a dispute arises.

If you are dealing with a foreign-related overtime dispute, compile the Chinese and English contracts, work permit, payroll, domestic and overseas bank records, attendance, meeting invitations and work product, then submit the basic facts through the consultation page. This article does not promise any case outcome.

The article is based on publicly available legislation, administrative regulations, departmental rules, judicial interpretations, local judicial documents and reported cases. It provides general legal information only and is not case-specific legal advice. Local practice varies, and any assessment should be based on the applicable local rules and the complete evidence.

Frequently asked questions

Legal authorities and cases
  • PRC Labor Law (2018 amendment), Articles 41 and 44: limits on extended hours and the 150%, 200% and 300% overtime rates.
  • PRC Labor Contract Law (2012 amendment), Articles 2 and 31: scope of application and the employer's duty to pay for arranged overtime.
  • PRC Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law, Articles 6 and 27: burden of proof and the one-year arbitration limitation.
  • PRC Law on the Application of Laws to Foreign-Related Civil Relations, Articles 4 and 43: mandatory provisions protecting labour rights and the law applicable to employment contracts.
  • Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China (2017 amendment), Articles 2, 5, 22 and 25: scope, employment permit, working time and rest, and labour-dispute handling.
  • Interim Provisions on Wage Payments, Article 13: overtime rates for working days, rest days and statutory public holidays, and the treatment of comprehensive and flexible working hours.
  • MOHRSS Notice 2008 No. 3, Article 2: the 21.75 monthly paid-day figure and hourly-rate conversion.
  • Measures for Holidays and Memorial Days of the Whole Nation (2024 amendment), Article 2: statutory public holidays.
  • SPC Interpretation (I) on Labour Disputes, Fa Shi [2020] No. 26, Articles 33 and 42: employment status without the required permit and the employee's initial burden of proving overtime.
  • SPC Interpretation (II) on Labour Disputes, Fa Shi [2025] No. 12, Articles 4 and 21: positive employment-status scenarios effective 1 September 2025 and the relationship with earlier interpretations.
  • PAOLOINGARAO v Shanghai Boxi Industrial Co., Ltd., (2016) Hu 0118 Min Chu No. 2560: a contractual clause excluding overtime pay did not displace mandatory working-time standards.
  • Zhang Jian v Xidis (Zhongshan) Technology Co., Ltd., (2018) Yue 20 Min Zhong No. 4877: an all-in salary, normal-working-time wage, attendance and actual payment practice affected the overtime analysis.
  • Emile (Shanghai) Machinery Co., Ltd. v Michael Malak, (2013) Hu 02 Min San (Min) Zhong Zi No. 527: the date the employment permit was obtained affected the start of the employment relationship.
  • OKUYAMAKEN v Sanhesheng Electronics Technology (Dongguan) Co., Ltd., (2014) Shen Zhong Fa Lao Zhong No. 2536: emails alone were insufficient to prove the full overtime duration.
  • Zhao Zhenlong v Zhuzhou CRRC Times Electric Co., Ltd., (2021) Xiang 0204 Min Chu No. 610: the employment relationship during an overseas posting depended on the contracting, payroll and management arrangements.
  • Meng v Anhui Construction Engineering Co., Ltd., (2023) Wan 01 Min Zhong No. 13374: a PRC employer and overseas workplace did not remove statutory holiday overtime obligations.
  • The cases above are public judgments or typical cases used to illustrate reasoning. They are not guiding cases and do not bind other courts; outcomes depend on the forum and the complete evidence.

Typical cases and ordinary judgments do not carry the normative force of statutes or judicial interpretations; they illustrate judicial reasoning only.

Open the overtime pay calculatorCalculate 150%, 200% and 300% overtime under standard, comprehensive and flexible working hours.Read why overtime uses 21.75 daysThe monthly paid-day figure, hourly rate and the three statutory multipliers.Check eligibility and jurisdictionCheck whether PRC labour law applies and which dispute forum is likely to have jurisdiction.Submit a consultation enquiryFor work-permit issues, cross-border salary, special working hours or overseas evidence, submit the basic facts for assessment.

This site provides automated calculations and general information only. It is not legal advice.