Key points
- A foreign national who has not lawfully obtained the required employment documents will generally not be treated as an employee, so statutory double wages, severance, unlawful-termination compensation and work-injury benefits are usually unavailable under the Labor Contract Law.
- “No employment relationship” does not mean the work was unpaid. Wages for work already performed and actual losses caused by the employer's fault may still be pursued through civil-law routes.
- From 1 September 2025, Article 4 of the 2025 Judicial Interpretation uses three positive scenarios to define when a foreign worker may establish an employment relationship.
- Permanent residence, a valid work permit with lawful stay and residence, and completion of procedures under relevant State rules are the first questions to examine.
- Unlawful employment also creates administrative exposure, including fines, detention and possible expulsion. The personal compliance position should be assessed before starting arbitration or litigation.
Opening case | A British designer worked for a Shanghai company for two years before being dismissed. He applied for labor arbitration and claimed compensation for unlawful termination. The company’s only defence was: “He never obtained a work permit. Why should we pay under the Labor Contract Law?” The statement is half right and half wrong. This article explains where the line lies.
1. Core conclusion: three levels of analysis
First level: a foreign national who has not lawfully obtained the required employment documents will generally not be recognised as an employee.
The rights that the Labor Contract Law reserves for an “employee” are generally unavailable. These include double wages for the absence of a written contract, severance on termination, compensation for unlawful termination, work-injury recognition and work-injury insurance benefits, and unemployment-insurance benefits.
Second level: not being an employee does not mean working for nothing.
The employer must still pay for work actually performed. That obligation does not depend on whether an employment relationship exists. If the missing permit resulted from the employer’s fault, the worker may also claim actual losses through a civil-law route, including wage shortfalls or losses caused by the failure to make statutory social-insurance contributions.
The boundary matters: those remedies address work already performed and actual losses only. Statutory severance, unlawful-termination compensation and work-injury benefits will generally remain unavailable. An employer’s fault may create civil liability, but it does not retroactively create an employment relationship.
Third level: the rule changed in 2025.
From 1 September 2025, the Supreme People’s Court’s new judicial interpretation uses a positive list. A foreign national who falls within one of three listed scenarios may ask a court to confirm an employment relationship.
2. Why the permit matters
Employment of foreigners in China is an administrative licensing matter. It is not something the employer and worker can create solely by agreement.
Article 41 of the Exit and Entry Administration Law provides:
A foreigner working in China shall obtain a work permit and a work-type residence permit in accordance with the law. No entity or individual may employ a foreigner who has not obtained a work permit and a work-type residence permit.
Article 5 of the Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners further states:
To employ a foreigner, an employer shall apply for an employment permit for that foreigner and may employ the foreigner only after obtaining the PRC Foreigner Employment Permit Certificate.
The normal process has three steps: enter on a Z visa, obtain a work permit, and obtain a work-type residence permit. Missing any step may bring the case within the definition of “unlawful employment” in Article 43 of the Exit and Entry Administration Law.
There is one express exception: a person holding a Chinese Permanent Residence Permit may work without an employment permit under Article 4 of the Measures on the Treatment of Foreigners with Permanent Residence in China.
The employer bears the statutory duty to initiate and obtain the employment permit, although the foreign worker must normally cooperate by supplying a passport, degree-authentication documents and a criminal-record certificate. Responsibility for the failure directly affects any fault-based damages claim. It does not, however, cure the missing legal capacity and create an employment relationship by itself.
3. The old rule: no employment permit, no employment relationship
Article 33(1) of the 2021 Interpretation (I) on Labor Disputes provided:
Where a foreigner or stateless person signs a labor contract with an employer in China without lawfully obtaining an employment permit, a request to confirm an employment relationship with the employer shall not be supported.
For several years, courts treated the absence of the required permit as a bar to employee status and therefore to the application of the Labor Contract Law.
4. The new rule: three positive scenarios from 1 September 2025
On 31 July 2025, the Supreme People’s Court issued Interpretation (II) on Labor Disputes, Fa Shi [2025] No. 12, effective 1 September 2025. Article 4 provides:
Where a foreigner establishes a work relationship with an employer in China, a request by the foreigner to confirm an employment relationship shall be supported in any of the following circumstances:
(1) the foreigner has obtained permanent residence status;
(2) the foreigner has obtained a work permit and is lawfully staying and residing in China;
(3) the foreigner has completed the relevant procedures in accordance with relevant State rules.
The provision turns the analysis into a positive list:
| Scenario | Typical position | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Permanent residence obtained | Holder of a Chinese Permanent Residence Permit | Employment relationship may be recognised; no employment permit required |
| Work permit obtained and lawful stay and residence | Foreign national with a valid work permit and residence status | Employment relationship may be recognised |
| Relevant State procedures completed | Chief representative or representative of a foreign enterprise’s permanent office, among others | Recognition according to the applicable rules |
Article 21 of Interpretation (II) states that it takes effect on 1 September 2025 and that earlier judicial interpretations inconsistent with it are superseded. The core question is therefore no longer simply whether a permit exists. It is whether the person falls within one of the three positive scenarios.
5. Four common factual patterns
Pattern 1: the permit process was fully lawful.
The worker enjoys the full protection of the Labor Contract Law, including wages, overtime, annual leave, severance and work-injury protection.
Pattern 2: permanent residence but no employment permit.
In a Nanjing Intermediate People’s Court typical case, a Singaporean national held a Chinese Permanent Residence Permit but no employment permit. The court held that he could establish an employment relationship with a Chinese company. The company’s failure to negotiate an open-ended contract before termination resulted in unlawful termination and a compensation award.
Pattern 3: no permit at all and unlawful employment.
Because the arrangement breaches mandatory rules, the relationship will generally be treated as a civil-service or contractual relationship governed by the Civil Code rather than the Labor Contract Law.
Pattern 4: work before the permit was obtained, or after it expired.
In a Qingdao case, the intermediate court treated the relationship as beginning on the date the foreigner obtained the employment permit. The earlier period was treated as a civil-service relationship. The date on which the permit was first obtained can therefore determine the counted service period for severance.
6. Claims that will generally fail without employee status
If an employment relationship is not recognised, the following claims will normally fail:
- double wages for the absence of a written labor contract;
- compensation for unlawful termination;
- severance on termination or expiry;
- losses relating to unemployment-insurance benefits; and
- work-injury recognition and work-injury insurance benefits.
This is the practical boundary that must be understood before choosing a remedy.
7. Claims that may still be available
7.1 Payment for work performed
Article 41 of Interpretation (I) confirms that where a labor contract is invalid but work has been performed, the employer must pay labor remuneration. A civil-service relationship also requires the recipient of the services to pay the agreed or reasonable value of the work.
7.2 Actual losses caused by the employer’s fault
Article 41(2) provides that where an invalid labor contract was caused by the employer and resulted in loss, the employer must compensate the loss. Depending on the evidence, this may include wage shortfalls caused by the invalidity, social-insurance losses or other reliance losses.
The employer’s failure to obtain a permit creates fault-based civil liability for actual loss. It does not create a claim to statutory severance or unlawful-termination compensation and does not convert the relationship into employment. If the employee refused to cooperate, the employer’s liability may be reduced or excluded.
7.3 Severance: a limited and inconsistent route
Article 41 of Interpretation (I) also refers to payment of labor remuneration and severance under Articles 28, 46 and 47 of the Labor Contract Law. Some courts have used this provision to support severance after first describing the labor contract as invalid.
In a 2024 typical case published by the Guangdong High People’s Court and the Guangdong Human Resources and Social Security Department, the Qingyuan Intermediate People’s Court held that an employer that failed to obtain an employment permit remained liable to pay wages and termination severance. The decision is a notable signal, but it is a typical case rather than a guiding case. Outcomes remain fact-sensitive and inconsistent between localities.
7.4 Overtime, annual leave and reimbursement
In a civil-service relationship these are not statutory employment rights, but they may still be claimed where the contract provides for them or where a stable course of dealing has made them part of the remuneration.
7.5 Injury at work
Without an employment relationship, work-injury recognition is generally unavailable. The worker may instead pursue tort or service-provider liability for medical expenses, lost income, care costs, disability compensation and other losses.
8. Administrative risk: the foreign worker may also be penalised
Article 80 of the Exit and Entry Administration Law provides for a fine of RMB 5,000 to RMB 20,000 for unlawful employment. In serious cases, the penalty may include detention of five to fifteen days and a fine of RMB 5,000 to RMB 20,000.
Article 81 permits expulsion in serious cases. A person expelled from China may be prohibited from re-entering for ten years.
The employer may also be fined RMB 10,000 for each foreign national unlawfully employed, subject to an aggregate cap, and may have unlawful gains confiscated.
Both sides therefore face legal risk. A wage claim should not be pursued without first assessing whether it could expose the worker to expulsion or a re-entry ban. A lawyer should review the immigration and employment facts before arbitration or litigation begins.
9. Five practical steps for foreign workers
- Check the three documents before starting work: the correct visa, the work permit and the work-type residence permit. A permanent residence permit holder is treated differently.
- Put the employer on written notice to complete the permit process. Emails and messages create a record of who was responsible for the delay.
- Preserve employment evidence: the contract, payslips, bank records, attendance data, work emails and access records.
- Record the date the permit was obtained. Where the relationship is divided by time, that date may determine the counted service period.
- Choose the correct forum. If labor arbitration refuses the case for lack of employee status, consider a civil claim based on contract, pre-contractual fault or tort. The eligibility and jurisdiction checker can help identify the preliminary route.
10. Conclusion
A work permit may look like an administrative formality, but it determines whether the Labor Contract Law or the Civil Code supplies the legal framework.
The law does not allow an employer to take the benefit of work without payment. It also does not apply the entire Labor Contract Law to a person who lacks the legal capacity to be an employee. The employer’s fault may create civil liability, but it does not automatically create statutory severance or compensation.
After 1 September 2025, the question is no longer only whether a permit existed. It is which positive category applies.
Disclaimer: The legal materials in this article were reviewed through October 2026. It provides general legal information only and is not case-specific legal advice. If you face an unpaid-wage, dismissal, permit or administrative-risk issue, submit the basic facts through the consultation page before choosing a procedural route.
Frequently asked questions
Can a foreign worker without a work permit still apply for labor arbitration?
If the facts do not satisfy the legal capacity requirements for an employment relationship, the labor arbitration commission may refuse to accept the case, reject the claim or direct the parties to civil litigation. Whether arbitration is available depends on the facts, the relief sought and local procedural practice, so neither acceptance nor refusal should be assumed in advance.
If the employer never obtained a work permit, can the employee still recover unpaid wages?
Work already performed normally requires payment. If an employment relationship is not established, the claim may be based on an invalid labor contract, a civil-service relationship or general civil-law rules. Statutory severance and unlawful-termination compensation do not automatically arise merely because the employer was at fault.
The employer says I failed to provide the required documents. Does that affect my claim?
Yes. Responsibility for the missing permit directly affects the existence and scope of the employer's fault-based liability. Liability may be reduced or excluded where the employee unjustifiably refused to cooperate, supplied false documents or asked the employer not to apply.
Do I still need an employment permit if I hold a Chinese permanent residence permit?
Under current rules, a foreign national holding a Chinese Permanent Residence Permit may work in China without an employment permit. Article 4(1) of the 2025 Judicial Interpretation also treats permanent residence as a positive basis for recognising an employment relationship.
If my work permit expired or was obtained later, how is the earlier period treated?
Courts may divide the relationship by time, treating the period before the permit as a civil-service relationship and the period after the permit as employment. The date on which the work permit was first obtained may therefore determine the service period used for severance.
Legal authorities and cases
- PRC Exit and Entry Administration Law, Articles 41, 43, 80 and 81: work permits, unlawful employment, fines, detention and expulsion.
- Provisions on the Administration of Employment of Foreigners in China, Articles 5 and 8: the employer's duty to apply for an employment permit and the Z visa, employment permit and residence-permit process.
- Measures on the Treatment of Foreigners with Permanent Residence in China, Article 4: holders of a Permanent Residence Permit may work without an employment permit.
- Supreme People's Court Interpretation (I) on Labor Disputes, Articles 33 and 41; Article 32(1) was repealed by Article 21 of Interpretation (II).
- Supreme People's Court Interpretation (II) on Labor Disputes, Fa Shi [2025] No. 12, Articles 4 and 21: effective 1 September 2025 and establishing the three positive scenarios and priority rule.
- PRC Labor Contract Law, Articles 28 and 47: wages after an invalid labor contract and the calculation of severance.
- Ya v a restaurant: a 2024 typical labor dispute case jointly published by the Guangdong High People's Court and the Guangdong Human Resources and Social Security Department, decided by the Qingyuan Intermediate People's Court. The case supported wages and termination severance notwithstanding an invalid labor contract, but it is a typical case rather than a guiding case and has no general binding force.
- Lu v a Nanjing machinery company: a 2021 top-ten labor and personnel dispute case published by the Nanjing Intermediate People's Court, holding that a permanent residence permit holder could establish an employment relationship without an employment permit.
- Han Je-hoon v Qingdao Youyou E-Commerce Co., Ltd.: first instance (2020) Lu 0214 Min Chu No. 3515; second instance (2021) Lu 02 Min Zhong No. 3557. The appellate court used the date on which the foreigner obtained the employment permit as the starting point of the employment relationship.
Typical cases and ordinary judgments do not carry the normative force of statutes or judicial interpretations; they illustrate judicial reasoning only.
This site provides automated calculations and general information only. It is not legal advice.