Key points

  • Article 43 of the Labor Contract Law requires an employer to notify its trade union of the reasons before unilaterally terminating an employment contract.
  • A valid substantive ground does not automatically make the termination procedure lawful. Where the employer has a union and fails to give the required notice, the dismissal may be held unlawful.
  • An employer may cure the procedure before litigation. This is the key risk window for employees, because arbitration is not the final deadline.
  • An unlawful dismissal commonly leads to 2N compensation. Reinstatement and 2N are ordinarily alternatives, not cumulative remedies.
  • Where the employer has no union, local practice differs on whether notice to the local union or employee representatives is required.

Opening note | Many employees focus entirely on the substantive dispute, arguing that they did not breach discipline or that the employer’s alleged loss is unsupported. They overlook a separate procedural question: before unilaterally terminating the contract, did the employer notify its trade union of the reasons? A valid substantive ground does not automatically make the procedure lawful. Where a union exists and the required notice was not given, the dismissal may be held unlawful and the claim may shift from N to 2N.

1. What Article 43 requires

Article 43 of the PRC Labor Contract Law provides:

Where an employer unilaterally terminates an employment contract, it shall notify the trade union of the reasons in advance. Where the employer violates laws, administrative regulations or the contract, the trade union has the right to require correction. The employer shall study the union’s opinions and notify the union in writing of the outcome.

The provision contains three requirements:

  1. Advance notice: the reasons must be given to the union before the termination decision is made.
  2. Right to object: the union may require correction where the ground is unlawful or contrary to the contract.
  3. Written response: the employer must consider the union’s views and notify it in writing of the outcome.

The same rule appears in Article 21(2) of the Trade Union Law. Article 30 of the Labor Law also gives a union the right to object where it considers a termination inappropriate.

The union notice is therefore not an optional internal step. It is a statutory duty that applies to unilateral termination.

2. Different termination routes require different procedures

Article 39, Article 40 and Article 41 dismissals cannot be treated as if they follow the same procedure.

Ground Main procedural requirement
Article 39 (fault-based dismissal) Notify the union of the reasons before dismissal
Article 40 (no-fault dismissal) Give 30 days written notice or one month’s pay in lieu of notice, and notify the union in advance
Article 41 (economic layoff) Explain the position to the union or all employees 30 days in advance, hear their views and report the layoff plan to the labor administration

Procedural defects in Article 39 and Article 40 cases may fall within the pre-litigation cure rule. An Article 41 layoff cannot simply rely on that cure and must also complete the labour-administration reporting step.

3. Does failure to notify the union make the dismissal unlawful?

Article 47 of the SPC Interpretation (I) on Labor Disputes provides:

Where an employer that has established a trade union terminates an employment contract in accordance with Articles 39 or 40 of the Labor Contract Law but fails to notify the union in advance under Article 43, and the employee claims compensation on the ground that the termination is unlawful, the people’s court shall support the claim, unless the employer has cured the procedure before litigation.

The rule applies where three conditions are present:

  1. the employer has established a trade union;
  2. the termination relies on Article 39 or Article 40 and the substantive ground is valid; and
  3. the employer neither gave advance notice nor cured the procedure before litigation.

Some employers argue that the termination must be lawful simply because the employee breached discipline, underperformed or the objective circumstances changed. The case law draws a clear line between the substantive ground and the procedure. A valid reason does not cure a defective procedure.

The Interpretation is marked partly invalid in the official database, but Articles 44 and 47 remain effective. Article 21 of the 2025 Interpretation (II) repealed only Article 32(1) of Interpretation (I), not the union-procedure provision.

4. Consequences of unlawful dismissal: 2N and reinstatement

If the dismissal is unlawful, the consequences are set out in Articles 48 and 87 of the Labor Contract Law.

The employee may:

  1. demand reinstatement; or
  2. not seek reinstatement, or the contract can no longer be performed, and claim 2N compensation.

2N is calculated at twice the severance standard under Article 47. Once compensation is paid, no separate severance is payable, and the counted service period runs from the first day of employment.

Three common misunderstandings:

  • 2N is not N plus 2N. The compensation replaces severance.
  • Pay in lieu of notice is not part of 2N. N+1 and 2N arise from different termination paths and cannot be combined into 2N+1.
  • The wage base still follows Article 47 and Article 27 of the Implementing Rules. It is average gross pay over the previous 12 months, including time or piece rates, bonuses, allowances and subsidies.

Article 53 of the Trade Union Law provides a further remedy in specific cases. Where an employee is dismissed for participating in union activities, or a union officer is dismissed for performing statutory duties, the labour administration may order reinstatement and back pay, or order compensation equal to twice the person’s annual income.

5. The employer’s cure: the key deadline

Article 47 leaves room for the employer to cure the procedure, but the timing is critical:

unless the employer has cured the procedure before litigation.

The wording is “before litigation”, not “before arbitration” or “before dismissal”. Nanjing Intermediate People’s Court has held that the cure deadline is before the court claim is filed and that there is no legal basis for imposing an earlier arbitration deadline.

This cuts both ways.

For employees, the risk is that the employer may cure the procedure between the dismissal notice and the filing of the court case. Winning at arbitration does not guarantee that the outcome will survive litigation. In one Shenyang case, the employer cured the procedure after the dismissal, the appellate court reversed the first-instance compensation award and the dismissal was no longer treated as unlawful.

For employees, the opportunity is that a cure attempted after the litigation deadline is no longer effective. In several local cases, employers failed to cure before litigation and were held liable for unlawful dismissal.

An employee who receives a dismissal notice should therefore preserve evidence of the missing union notice early, rather than waiting for the arbitration outcome.

6. What if the employer has no union?

This is the most contested issue and a common defence. There are three broad approaches.

First, a literal reading. Article 47 refers to an employer that has “established a trade union”. An employer without a union may argue that the provision does not apply.

Second, notice to the local union. Some local regulations expressly require notice to the local union where the employer has no union. Article 31(2) of the Jiangsu Labor Contract Regulations is an example. Jiangsu courts have treated union notice as a statutory procedure that does not depend on whether the employer has established a union.

Third, alternative compliance. Where there is no local regulation, some courts require the employer to consult employee representatives or seek the views of the local union. Others have held that accepting “no union, no notice” would encourage employers not to establish unions and contradict the purpose of the legislation.

The trend is against the argument that no union means no obligation. However, the required form of alternative compliance is not uniform, and the outcome depends on local practice.

7. What counts as an effective cure?

A cure is not a formality. Courts normally examine three elements:

  1. A genuine recipient: the employer’s own union, the local union or lawfully selected employee representatives.
  2. Actual reasons: the recipient must be able to see the grounds for dismissal, not merely a statement that notice was given.
  3. Verifiable records: written notice, receipt records, minutes, emails or other traceable communications.

An internal management meeting record alone is usually insufficient. By contrast, notifying the union before the dismissal and retaining the receipt and response normally supports compliance with Article 43.

The standards are not uniform. Where the substantive ground is valid, notice was not given and no effective cure was completed before litigation, a finding of unlawful dismissal is more likely. This still depends on the evidence and the local forum.

8. Burden of proof and evidence checklist

The employer bears the main burden of proof.

Under Article 44 of Interpretation (I), where a dispute arises from an employer’s decision to dismiss, remove, terminate or reduce pay, the employer must prove that the decision was lawful. The employer ordinarily must show:

  • the substantive ground for dismissal;
  • that the relevant rules were adopted through a democratic procedure and published or communicated; and
  • that the union procedure was completed.

The employee should still preserve:

  1. The termination notice: the date, reasons and legal basis stated in the document. The employer should not be allowed to replace the stated reason later without explanation.
  2. Evidence of a union: union officers, union dues, union notices, union clauses in the handbook, a union seal or documents issued in the union’s name.
  3. Evidence against the substantive ground: attendance records, rosters, payroll, performance communications and work-group messages.
  4. Communications about the union procedure: emails, WeChat messages or written requests asking whether the union was notified.
  5. Limitation evidence: proof of receipt of the dismissal notice, email delivery and the final working day.

In a union-procedure dispute, the order of proof matters: establish the dismissal, show that the procedure was not completed, and then answer the employer’s substantive allegations.

9. Three practical points for employees

First, do not focus only on the substantive ground. An employer may be able to prove misconduct or loss but still fail to prove that the union was notified. The receipt and response records are usually held by the employer, so the employee should raise the procedural issue early.

Second, “we have no union” is not an automatic defence. Local regulations and judicial practice may require notice to the local union or consultation with employee representatives.

Third, watch the pre-litigation deadline. The employer’s cure window runs until the court claim is filed. Delay gives the employer more opportunities to cure. Evidence should be collected and the procedural issue raised as soon as possible.

10. Four compliance points for employers

  • Notify the union in writing before a unilateral dismissal, obtain a receipt, consider the union’s views and respond in writing.
  • If there is no union, notify the local union or consult employee representatives as required by local rules, and keep evidence.
  • State the dismissal reason clearly in the notice and ensure that the reason matches the evidence.
  • The Article 41 layoff procedure is stricter, cannot simply rely on the pre-litigation cure rule and requires a report to the labour administration.

If you have been dismissed and need to assess whether the employer completed the union procedure, compile the termination notice, service dates, wage records and any evidence concerning the existence of a union, then submit the basic facts through the consultation page. This article does not promise any case outcome.

The article is based on publicly available legislation, administrative regulations, local regulations, judicial interpretations and reported cases. It provides general legal information only and is not case-specific legal advice. Local practice differs, and any assessment should be based on the applicable local rules and the complete evidence.

Frequently asked questions

Legal authorities and cases
  • PRC Labor Contract Law (2012 amendment), Articles 39, 40, 41, 43, 48 and 87: unilateral termination, union procedure, unlawful termination and double compensation.
  • PRC Trade Union Law (2021 amendment, effective 1 January 2022), Article 21(2): an enterprise must notify the trade union of the reasons before unilaterally terminating an employee's labor contract; Article 53: remedies where an employee is dismissed for participating in union activities or a union officer is dismissed for performing statutory duties.
  • PRC Labor Law (2018 amendment), Article 30: a trade union may raise objections where it considers a termination inappropriate.
  • PRC Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Law, Articles 5 and 27: arbitration before litigation and the one-year limitation period.
  • PRC Implementing Rules of the Labor Contract Law, Articles 25 and 27: payment under Article 87 replaces severance; the severance wage base is gross pay.
  • SPC Interpretation (I) on Labor Disputes, Fa Shi [2020] No. 26, Articles 44 and 47: employer's burden of proof and the unlawful-dismissal consequence where a unionized employer fails to notify the union, subject to a pre-litigation cure. The Interpretation is marked as partly invalid, but Articles 44 and 47 have not been repealed.
  • SPC Interpretation (II) on Labor Disputes, Fa Shi [2025] No. 12, Article 21: effective 1 September 2025 and repealing Article 32(1) of Interpretation (I).
  • Jiangsu Labor Contract Regulations (2013 amendment), Article 31(2): where an employer has not established a union, notice is given to the local union. This provision applies only in Jiangsu.
  • Tianjin First Intermediate People's Court (2024) Jin 01 Min Zhong No. 9922: the employer had a union but failed to notify it before dismissal, and the dismissal was held unlawful.
  • Nanjing Intermediate People's Court (2018) Su 01 Min Zhong No. 1640 and Jiangsu High People's Court (2018) Su Min Shen No. 4140: the cure deadline under the judicial interpretation is before litigation, not before arbitration.
  • Shenyang Intermediate People's Court (2021) Liao 01 Min Zhong No. 5244: a post-dismissal cure prevented the dismissal from being treated as unlawful, and the first-instance compensation award was reversed.
  • Suzhou Intermediate People's Court (2019) Su 05 Min Zhong No. 8245, Huai'an Intermediate People's Court (2023) Su 08 Min Zhong No. 178, and Shijiazhuang Chang'an District People's Court (2020) Ji 0102 Min Chu No. 2957: the dismissal was unlawful because the union procedure was not effectively cured before litigation.
  • Shaoyang Intermediate People's Court (2020) Xiang 05 Min Zhong No. 734 and Nanping Yanping District People's Court (2021) Min 0702 Min Chu No. 4619: rejecting the argument that no union means no notice obligation.
  • Hangzhou Intermediate People's Court (2024) Zhe 01 Min Zhong No. 8933: the employer relied on a self-generated loss statement and failed to notify the union before dismissal, and was ordered to pay compensation.
  • Typical cases from the Chongqing Fourth Intermediate People's Court, Nantong Intermediate People's Court (2015) and Guangzhou courts (2015): these are typical or ordinary cases and are used only to illustrate judicial reasoning; they do not have the binding force of guiding cases.

Typical cases and ordinary judgments do not carry the normative force of statutes or judicial interpretations; they illustrate judicial reasoning only.

Open the severance and compensation calculatorEstimate N, N+1 or 2N by dismissal scenario, with the three-times cap and service limits.Read N, N+1 and 2N explainedIdentify the termination route before deciding between severance, pay in lieu and 2N.Check eligibility and jurisdictionCheck whether PRC labor law applies and which dispute forum is likely to have jurisdiction.Submit a consultation enquiryFor termination notices, union procedure, evidence review or higher-value disputes, submit the basic facts for assessment.

This site provides automated calculations and general information only. It is not legal advice.